• You can now help support WorldwideDX when you shop on Amazon at no additional cost to you! Simply follow this Shop on Amazon link first and a portion of any purchase is sent to WorldwideDX to help with site costs.
  • The Feb 2025 Radioddity Giveaway Results are In! Click Here to see who won!

Reply to thread

I'm only going to show this...because with everything else being equal...


Meaning RESONANCE - all elements used are EQUAL length...


Ok, one thread did not seem to help me get my point across.


It deals with how FEEDPOINT Impedance versus SWR - even if RESONATE - why SWR?


Look back at this post...


https://www.worldwidedx.com/threads/is-resonance-really-where-you-get-best-antenna-performance.262791/#post-775830


The Graphic in there is what I want you to think about - for if ALL THINGS except orientation of elements are equal, then FEEDPOINT Impedance and the SWR from it - does it become moot? As in discardable?


Read the rest of the thread for there is a device on page 4(?) that does a wonderful job of fixing specific things wrong with SWR even when everything else is equal.


We keep trying to put the cart before the horse...


Because with a 102" whip being the physical length and its construction - is not exactly favorable for any type of easy or simple install - it has needs - so we must put it in an ideal spot - not the spot we want it to be - which makes the answer your question "What Am I Missing Here?" Not a simple as it seems - for there are many factors we must deal with but location being one of them, cannot always make it work well for the situation were in.


Ok, we can't put a 102" whip on top of a semi - well we could - but the DOT is going to have a say or two about that once we start seeing the number of damages to street signs, streetlights and even stop lights - that whip will thwack against - to the point of both members the antenna and the object it strikes - will be compromised and not work well anymore - at least, effectively.

[ATTACH=full]48848[/ATTACH]


So, I just wanted to help answer your question by giving you a carrot - and then you can run down any rabbit hole you choose to feed your desire...