It appears that it's doing what it's supposed to be doing, matching impedances between the radio/amplifier and the antenna system. The antenna system's impedance hasn't been changed at all, it's the same as it was before inserting the tuner in-line. That's all that any tuner does.
The best place to put that tuner would be at the base of the antenna, at the antenna's feed point. Then, it would be matching the feed line and amplifier, and radio's impedance to that of the antenna. That would eliminate any of the losses associated with the feed line. There would still be some small losses associated with the tuner, but that would be nothing compared to the losses with the feed line -and- antenna combination.
I would pay particular attention to the wording of the advertiing/instructions, it isn't saying what you may think it does. The power rating for instance, refers to 'peak' power. That's only 'half' of 'peak to peak', or 'Pep' power. Don't count on it handling 1000 watts, closer to 500 watts, maybe. Simple to check, just feel it after a few minutes use. Is it warm to the touch? Shouldn't be, and if it is, you're feeding it too much power.
I don't have a problem with using a tuner -IF- it's used correctly. They don't do 'miracles'.
- 'Doc