i don't have any first hand reports with either but I did know a guy back on my cb days that ran the Wilson SuperLaser 500 (same as the Maco). He had it mounted about 40 feet up, the element just cleared the roof. Seemed to work good, had a Tram D201a hooked to it.
In my opinion that is a lot of money to waste on only 440khz of band space.
In my opinion that is a lot of money to waste on only 440khz of band space.