Your right, I was in the discusion with toll free about the device itself and then about the amplifier as a whole. Without knowing the Q of the filters, I have no clue how hard you could push the amp before killing the overall IMD. Im guessing no matter what, its better than an sb220. They were never required to meet IMD specs since they were a kit. I think I heard best IMD product was -35db. FCC requires 43db.
They met IMD requirements as of the date of MFG.
ALSO, they do better than -35. Thats Eimacs number, the nfb on the grids //supposedly\\ increases that number: The caveat, you get worse imd out of the exciter.
Incidentally, VE7RF has compared the SB220's output to an Alpha. They where the same at the same Pout.
ALL Motorola RF devices are rated at 30 to 1 SWR "at all phase angles", except nobody has blown an MRF477 in a 2510 / Lincoln / 2600, have they? Any MRF devices blown in the 80s or 90s due to swr, antenna issues, etc? Oh yeah...... The Toshiba devices where actually WAY MORE RUGGED, and they won't go into a 30 to 1 swr.......
Tubes have guidelines, transistors have RATINGS. That was my tagline for years, and it still holds true today.
You go ahead and push YOUR MRF150s, volt them, run them into a 30 to 1 swr (I mean, Ameritron is USED to wasting money on things like VSWR overprotection, right), say what you want.
BUT, the fact remains... At 55 watts PER device, they ARE blowing up with a 2.5 to 1 swr, in Yahoo and other xceivers.. I'M NOT GOING TO PUSH MINE, just so I can make my Dosy swing farther to the right.
--Toll_Free