Hello John: Yes had the same problem with this antenna the Avanti Saturn. Many years ago some fellow CB'ers asked my to come by and look over their Saturn Antenna because the Horz side had a high VSWR but they were able to talk on the Horz side anyway. The Vert side VSWR was good and it worked great.
Looking over the assembly instructions and with my trusty highly calibrated tape measure from work, I checked everything was dead nutz on per the assembly instructions, and all connections tight. Even double checked it, thinking something had to be wrong. Swapped the Vert and Horz coaxes to see what happens, same result. Installed the Saturn Antenna all the way up on a 40 foot push up, no change.
Waked away not knowing what was wrong, the Horz matching system was and is a mystery to me. Not caring if I get humilated on the phone to the local CB Shops and even Avanti, no body home, nobody knows what the Horz problem is.
Had several phone calls asking the same question how to fix the Saturn Horz VSWR problem. One guy wanted to send me a Saturn and fix it for him, but then its not just a repair, but a design issue taking way more time and money. It would be a good project to put the Saturn up and fix it. Might be a simple fix or a major redesign!??!
Looking at the Saturns VSWR on a wide band analyzer to see if its working some were else on a near by frequency would be a start. Avanti had a over design problem with their antennas as compared to simpler designs in my opinion.
Jay in the Great Mojave Desert... "Next Gas 150 Miles"