spt500's are hard to beat
mines been up for 20+ years now just gets better with age !
5150, back in the day I had an old Starduster up for a long time too. I saw similar results...getting better with age I thought.
However, on taking it down I found the feed line had deteriorated due to moisture and that 100' line attenuated the heck out of my signal. On checking I put a 100 watts in, and got less than 10 watts out using a dummy load with a meter.
While I was working the setup on air, I noticed the SWR seemed to only get better and better, and bandwidth showed flat from 11 meters to 20, and that ain't right. I had buddies close by that commented that my ears were better than theirs, and I realized that too, but I could never explain, except to say it must be the old Starduster.
This antenna seemed to work very well for both TX/RX and for local and DX, so I wasn't ever alerted. I also didn't show my contacts a good signal like the other guys close by...and at some point this fact came to light. On taking this clear coat coax down I could see signs of deterioration to the shield at various points along the 100' run, and I cut it open to see. The shield was tarnished and looked of green mildew. The A99 is another similar antenna by design, but the SD'r feed point is uniquely bad a letting water go straight into the coax over time. The HSP500 may not be nearly as bad, but it looks like it might also let water in via the coax connector.
You might need to check your feed line for unusual loss if you see similar symptoms, but don't destroy the line like I did. I can't in good conscience recommend its re-use, but you may want to hook it back up...if you trust the line after such a discovery, or you find its use better than a new line like I did.
I would have never thought it possible, but it happened to me. I was really surprised at how little signal it can require to make a contact.