Hey Homer, why don't you tell us which antenna you're working too, and do you make comparisons?
Okay, Marconi. I can do that.
In the last set 1/25, The first two on the list, Ted and Tom, were from the mobile,using a center load large coil antenna.
All the rest were from the base using the 4 element Yagi which went back up last Saturday. I sold the 2 element Quad to a local who needed an antenna.
I switched back and forth between the Yagi and the Astroplane to adjust for fading, which i experienced rather rapidly most of the time. Usually it helped.
Normally, the Yagi was the stronger for receive, and those who were aware of the switch reported 1 - 2 S units difference on their meters. The bars on my RCI 2950 are not good for comparisons on receive.