Well that depends on your interests I guess. An amp on 80/160m is most certainly an asset but if you want to chase the serious DX especially DXpeditions then it becomes almost necessary in order to compete in a pile-up regardless of the antenna used. My propagation zone usually include the USA north-east where I have VERY stiff competition into Africa and I cannot even think of competing with stateside stations into the Pacific area. Been running 100 watts since I was licensed over 25 years ago and completely understand what 100 watts and even a three element tribander at 40 feet will do but the time has come to up the ante a little. I have a new Explorer-14 assembled on the ground right now with 40m kit to allow operation on four bands and a three element A3WS to add 12 and 17m. The Ex-14 will be at about 64 feet and the A3WS at about 70 feet. Not bad height and while not superb antennas they are quite capable all the same. I hope to get them up in the next few weeks. I have a cabinet and all power supply components for the amp most of which were gleaned from commercial AM or FM broadcast transmitters. The plate xmfr is about 80 pounds itself. The tube of choice is a 3CX3000A7 since I have several broadcast pulls and all the components to make it work including filament xmfr, socket, blower with air vane switch, and ridiculously over rated rectifiers and a nice pair of Jennings vacuum variable capacitors for the output network. When completed it should have one of the lowest weight to watts ratios ever. LOL Do I NEED it? No, like I said been doing this for 25+ years already. Will it be used? YES but only during pile-ups or when a bit of extra power is needed on 75 or 160m. Hitting the Pacific from Nova Scotia on 75m is pretty much impossible with just 100 watts. Been there, tried that, got the lumps to prove it. Will I feel pride and satisfaction in building it and making it work? YOU BETCHA!! I don't expect to finish it (or even get it started) for some time but I see it as therapy for when the bands are dead. My wife just sees it as the workings of an evil scientist making yet another lethal device.
You are absolutely right, however, I am surrounded by power lines here, and can't get a dipole antenna higher than 30' without touching them, or coming close to touching them if something fell down in a storm. I'm in the north east also.
I bought a couple of semi decent amplifiers, didn't have to spend a lot of money to get them, but in some ways I wish I never would have bought them.
I realize if I want to talk on 75 or 160 that I need to put up a decent antenna, but I have computer equipment here that seems to crash when I try to use amplifiers, so I nixed that idea and I don't worry so much about how far I can talk anymore.
I do have several decent beam antennas, just never have the help when I try to dig the hole to put one up. I recently traded one of my beams for a used TA 34 with 40 m element. It's a monster.
The ground is hard, the gas company had to use a jackhammer attached to the front end of a backhoe just to dig a trench 3 feet deep to put the gas line in, and it shook the whole house. It's the same reason why the coal company chose the town as a place to put in a coal - deep mine 130 years ago.
I could move up to my dad's house, but then I would have to sell my house and put that money into dad's house just to make it livable.
I can't see putting $100,000 into a $10,000 house.
I would never have enough money in my lifetime to build a new house or purchase a double wide and put it on a foundation.
That is why 6, 10, 20, 40 meters is so alluring to me.
Thanks for sharing your QTH info with me.
I would have thought that you would have already had a Lightning Jerker set up in place already the way to seem to know it all - about radio..