Thanks, BM
I did do it with pipe all the way out, but never posted a photo of it like that. I figured that a different installation on a different part of the vehicle, or even on a different automobile would result in a different SWR curve. Also, I had that really nice chromed heavy stinger that I wanted to put on top of it.
I have driven with it on the roof only about 5 miles @ 50 MPH maximum speed. It is heavy and noisy, so I haven't done any more with it. I had a friend in mind when I did it. It may work well for him directly behind his pickup truck cab. I haven't checked how wide banded it is as I think he only runs 40 channels.
It seemed rigid enough so far, but time and higher speeds would tell more. I will check both it, and this one I threw together yesterday, out more today.
No testing done on this other than to temporarily mount it on the SUV and check SWR on CB band. More finessing it to be done, but it works.