i do not know enough to have opinions here, i just state what is in the patent sheet.
the patent sheet says two things that interest me here.
1. "the pair of CONDUCTOR MEMBERS are electrically connected at the lower level, and one of the CONDUCTOR MEMBERS is electrically connected at the upper level to the first conductor and to a PROJECTING CONDUCTOR which extends upwardly from that upper level. THE PROJECTING CONDUCTOR HAS AN EFFECTIVE ELECTRICAL LENGTH EQUAL TO THE LENGTH OF THE CONDUCTOR MEMBERS."
(caps used for clarification, not for "yelling")
2. "the electrical circuit of the antenna in fig. 2 is illustrated schematically in fig.5. DIMENSIONS A AND B ARE EACH ONE QUARTER WAVELENGTH IN ELECTRICAL LENGTH"
if you look at the diagram referred to, you can see that A is the top radiator with the horizontal radials.
B is the bottom conductor members, and the hoop.
not one of the concuctor members, not just the hoop, but all three are included as part of "B".
see quote above.
again, i dont have any opinions, or interpretations, i believe that the patent sheet is quite clear about this.
my question to the antenna gurus here is this:
if the antenna IS a half wave antenna, then would the way it is fed make sense for a good match to 50 ohm coax?
loosecannon