Robb,
I'm not seeing any noticeable difference between the different types of caps. I have used non-polarized electrolytics, metal film, mylar, polyester film, ceramic disc and mica so far, and at least on the scope, it's not showing any real difference. It does make me wonder if there may be differences in the actual audio. Things that make you go "hmmm...".
The only important thing is that it has to be non-polarized, and must not exceed 1uf. The reason you don't want to exceed 1uf is because the final and AM pass regulator transistor just won't have enough headroom to support the extra current draw from the higher positive peaks. I tried a 2.2uf capacitor and it knocked out the stock AM pass regulator transistor pretty quickly, it overheated (2SC1419). I currently run 2SC1061 for a pass regulator, and that's a bit beefier than the stock 2SC1419 and even an NTE152, even though all 3 of those cross reference to each other. If you use a 1uf capacitor, I'd highly recommend installing a 2SC1061 or an NTE152 in place of the original 2SC1419.
I have since modded my Madison with an MRF477 final. This allows me more headroom to open up my AMC a little more to get more on the positive peaks before I start clipping on the negative peaks. However, I set it back to where it was when I had the C1969 final in it and left it alone.
~Cheers~