• You can now help support WorldwideDX when you shop on Amazon at no additional cost to you! Simply follow this Shop on Amazon link first and a portion of any purchase is sent to WorldwideDX to help with site costs.
  • Click here to find out how to win free radios from Retevis!

Palomar 400 Elite

144inBama

Sr. Member
Apr 22, 2020
761
1,352
153
55
Lower Alabama
What's the max output I should be seeing on this amp? I'm embarrassed to even say what I'm seeing because it seems impossible but my meter is accurate on all the other amps and radios I have. Using the 99V2, I'm dead keying 1watt, 20 watts with the amp on swinging to 40...the amp is swinging to just over 600 PEP and 175 AVG.... SWRs are perfect. She's not getting hot and getting good reports from the locals. This is the amp I bought from CB590.... is this even possible?
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20210131-113234_Video Player.jpg
    Screenshot_20210131-113234_Video Player.jpg
    601.8 KB · Views: 21

Well, if you know your Volta X Amps - got an Ammeter?

Install it in line at the power supply feed lines - to possibly be able to measure the input Amps into the box, then you'd have a good idea of how Forgiving or Accurate - Former more than latter - the meter you're using - really is.

If you run class C - plan on about 0.7 X the Ammeter reading to truly get an idea of dissipation + Conversion efficiency which would allow you to "re-rate" or mentally adjust what you're seeing into real power delivery.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 144inBama
Well, if you know your Volta X Amps - got an Ammeter?

Install it in line at the power supply feed lines - to possibly be able to measure the input Amps into the box, then you'd have a good idea of how Forgiving or Accurate - Former more than latter - the meter you're using - really is.

If you run class C - plan on about 0.7 X the Ammeter reading to truly get an idea of dissipation + Conversion efficiency which would allow you to "re-rate" or mentally adjust what you're seeing into real power delivery.

28 amps at load @14.5 VDC
 
So...

Watts = Volts x Amps

Watts = 14.5 x 28A

Watts = 406 Input watts

Possible output conversion - using 70% efficiency...

Potential Output Watts = 406 x 0.7

Output Watts = 284.x (Rounding)

I can easily see the 284 true watts RMS (Rounding up to an even 300 Watts can demonstrate this too) - but with 600 PEP? JMO Hmm...I've been the beat-up guy on where you'd get this result - but to me the Red Letters above show more of a true nature of the beast than to claim "Ghost watts" due to harmonics adding fluff - kinda hard to knock it out of the park except for overswing and read on further to explain more...

The MORE:

, I'm not sure of the LOAD you are using - for if it's an antenna - then the 2nd (including any higher n-th order) harmonic power output is possibly skewing your results - Antennas are REACTIVE and even if you can't get an SWR reflection to show - throw on the output - a means to measure, like a Spectrum Analyzer - on the mess to view and you'll see the 2nd order is still there - and it's power does skew readings - it's on everyone else's - no one is left out - so if you run the amp and keep the filters in place - you're numbers would be better. How? well others would have to chime in but those out there in the real world would know from listening, as well as the S-meter readings - from everyone else participating in this melee.

The potential errors come from PEP meters and their error correction for meter drive and levels - the sensors themselves work with what is present on the line, so if harmonics which are everyday thing - are present, no matter how accurate the readings may be, the load being the reactive element in this - we can not rule out errors in the readings no matter how "Calibrated" the equipment can be and is able to be.

  • So for CB590 to sell this amp, he may want it back. Especially if he needed a spare in todays current conditions.

Again, as the "Beat up guy" which really doesn't mean a hill of beans - if you can cook tomorrows breakfast using the Grease from tonight's Amp-Basted - Pork Roast - save the drippings for the sear marks. Because you'll need proof the Amp was really a giant cooker and sorry to be heard thru your toaster...as the main excuse.

Not saying it's bad, (Your numbers) not by a long shot. Just be realistic (Radio Shack or Bust...) about this.

Many use the numbers you're getting from your equipment before the Derating - as an EGO boost to their (ahemn) "attitude" about things...

The real meat and Winner Winner Chicken Dinner - is in how you get over them in the pileup.

Let's reverse engineer that wattage...

PEP - 600?

You say you have 14.5V DC?

Divide the 14.5 INTO that wattage figure...

Amps = 600 / 14.5

Amps = 41 Amps - you using pennies over there? Might want to use Quarters - and in Quarter-Inch Thick stock to handle that Buss Bar...

To add this to keep it in simplicity...

The 170~180 watt figure seems conservative when it comes to RMS or even AVG watts.

Knowing the conversion efficiency of the Amps I've seen in previous working environments, the 600W PEP sounds a bit much, as per the simpleton amps or E I R equations and their skewing of results based upon accuracy of readings and known variables that often get thrown out the window,,,

So to help you, the 280 Watt or 300 watt figure is a figure of Merit based upon the Facts present and shown in calculations. This would be of 70% efficiency - but If I try to de-rate to 50% which is more likely - the only value that applies in your readings is the 175 Watts as true Carrier (Dead key Class C) watts. The 600 PEP figure can't hold weight as being a true PEP figure of using the 4:1 (Modulation to Carrier properly set) ratio.

  • Then the Ammeter shows one thing scenario;
  • - so obviously the MPG on the Amp will vary - to it's OWN, it is on the side of better than expected - meaning your readings on the LOW end (your 170-180W) of that scale that does meet, beat and equate to the rules the Electrons must follow.
Now that may be total power going out - but not PEP - but too - the 175 if you look at ratios of 4:1 the 175 Carrier multiplied by that 4 - doesn't get you 600 it brings you to 700 - which your input watts don't show...

What this is demonstrating - is an error, in not the readings. But how to Interpret those readings that get made thru known trusted references - and then it get's beaten up and stomped to death as left to explain that the READING that can't be ignored, yet even understood; for is it true or just Ghost?

I'm being conservative to show that the AMP is easily capable of producing wattage for it's sticker, but it's SSB modes and Class_Taking_Chances_C to even be worth the guess as to it's true output level of getting clipped and squared-waved into where T-Mobile looks good on paper when it comes to 5G broad banding...You need the more realistic (There it is again) viewpoint of real numbers of known values to attain any sort of sense out of the otherwise senseless data

Each time I try to bring this down to a simple answer - to get to that result takes more explanation than to say - Hey! It Works! Leave it alone! Weld it shut...

 
Last edited:
Driving the tar out of them in stock trim 150 rms and 480 pep should be the max as in your life depends on it. I have seen people modify them, volt them and drive them to 500 but they do not last. 100 swinging to 300 is the hardest you should drive one if you want it to have any chance of living a long life assuming you are not long winded. You might have noticed the price of bipolar 12V rf transistors!

These normally have 4xMRF455's or 2SD1446 which are about the same thing in terms of what you should expect to put into it in drive and what you should expect it to dissipate. Sure you can rewrap the transformers and change the caps to install anything from a Toshiba 2290 to a HG 2879 but you are still limited by the board, heat sink and air flow. Think of it like dropping an LS V8 into a Miata and your using the Miata 4 clinder radiator, stock transmission and rear end and no space in the engine compartment for air to flow around the engine. So even if someone has droped more powerful transistors in it you still have a lot of limitations.

Pop the tins and see what transistor is in it. What ever the white paper says the stock rating is for each device is toss in some losses and limit your output to that.

Make sure it is not getting hotter than it should since that is a sure sign of harmonics!
 
Last edited:
Driving the tar out of them in stock trim 150 rms and 480 pep should be the max as in your life depends on it. I have seen people modify them, volt them and drive them to 500 but they do not last. 100 swinging to 300 is the hardest you should drive one if you want it to have any chance of living a long life assuming you are not long winded. You might have noticed the price of bipolar 12V rf transistors!

These normally have 4xMRF455's or 2SD1446 which are about the same thing in terms of what you should expect to put into it in drive and what you should expect it to dissipate. Sure you can rewrap the transformers and change the caps to install anything from a Toshiba 2290 to a HG 2879 but you are still limited by the board, heat sink and air flow. Think of it like dropping an LS V8 into a Miata and your using the Miata 4 cylinder radiator, stock transmission and rear end and no space in the engine compartment for air to flow around the engine. So even if someone has droped more powerful transistors in it you still have a lot of limitations.

Pop the tins and see what transistor is in it. What ever the white paper says the stock rating is for each device is toss in some losses and limit your output to that.

Make sure it is not getting hotter than it should since that is a sure sign of harmonics!

It has 1446s in it, everything looks good internally, best I can tell anyway. I did change a 1K cap out *see attachment* that was swollen and upgraded the power wire. I swapped out my Wilson 2K homemade mount for my Wilson 1K and it dropped down to about 490 (on the meter anyway). Heat? She doesn't really even get warm but I don't have long convos on SSB, I'll call out or reply, make contact, swap greetings and then she'll set idle for a couple of minutes before I key again. I do have a question (big surprise, I know..LOL), what is the large ceramic resistor in the left rear for? I only as because it's lifted on one end.
As far as input, I'll have to take the radio back to the tech and let him turn it down, I don't adjust other peoples work on new equipment, 2 years old, yeah I'll play around with it, but not a few weeks old.
 

Attachments

  • 20210131_092042.jpg
    20210131_092042.jpg
    2.6 MB · Views: 15

dxChat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.