1/8 of an s-unit is a difference of 0.75 dB. That is a smaller than the accuracy level of most S-meters, and small enough to be a completely irrelevant change in performance.
This is absolutely true, and the picture linked agrees with this as well. DX is a poor judge of antenna performance as mother nature on a daily basis can affect DX at a rate far more than the difference between these two antenna. Also, if the Wilson was tested while DX was building, and then the Sirio was tested when you were closer tot he peak of the cycle naturally you would have more contacts...
I'm not saying that the Sirio isn't a better performing antenna than the Wilson, I agree that it is based on numerous tests by people on this very forum, and the fact that it has a longer whip. But we seem to have a Sirio fanboy now that is taking it upon himself to try and brainwash the rest of us and bring us into his camp. While the Sirio's are generally better performing antennas than the Wilsons, that doesn't make them the best performing antenna you can buy for every mobile installation... AL567, you should try running a full length 1/4 wavelength whip and compare that to your Sirio performance wise...
The DB