Not to start up an old topic... seeing there was never any pictures... But if the antenna was horizontal, with the tip pointing to the north, wouldnt this talk east and west? He was probably getting his rejection from the fact it was mounted horizontal. Not because of the dish. Thats the take I took on it. I think this is the Null area many were talking about. Which would be directly in front of it, which is the actually direction he was intending to talk. Not to mention Id have to be proven the swr could actually get that low on such a contraption... And did I mention I seen guys talking off coke cans with a tuner... Worked, for like 1/2 mile of open field... NOT 200 miles.
I've built some crazy antennas, but are based on good theory, but nothing like this... I spend a LOT of time building, trying, tuning, and making new antenna. Love it! Yet I dont think I would have ever considered this one. :headbang