I completely understand where you are coming from, and can't argue with your logic. Unfortunately I have no need or want for an HF rig. I have had zero issues with the SSB performance on my optima, or the 2950dx and 955hp I had before. My issue is that I need good AM, and my current optima is the worst of the lot. The 2950 did pretty well on am, but the radio is really difficult to operate in the dark mobile. The 955 sounded great on AM and SSB, and was lit up so it could actually be used mobile. Unfortunatly the 955 had swr problems, along with hardware issues. I didnt want to send it back to stryker again, so I sold it. I guess I just expect too much
Okay, I'll add my opinion.
I currently have a Stryker 955HP. I use it as an alternate base radio with my RCI-2995DX-CF .
I have also used it mobil. I like the 955 very much. I have now had it for about 10~11 months. I have used it in all bands. With the frequency modifications, it will tune from 24.000 to 32.200 mhz. It has 4 mosfets in it. 13N10 mosfets is what it was manufactured with. It has lots of options to play with and choose from.
It will dead key on am from about 1 1/2 watts to about 33 watts. And swing up to close to 80 PEP. It will also swing to about 83 watts PEP on SSB. I use an Astatic D104M6B handheld microphone. It is loud and very clear. Speak with a normal soft voice.
Now then, it does drift on frequency when cold and then warming up. I keep the clarifier Rx & TX locked together because of this. No big deal breaker for me. After it is warmed up good, it does pretty good.
Magnum 1 ........ A very good friend of mine purchased this radio about 8 months ago. He let me use it for about two weeks on my bench so I could check it out.
This radio is very solid on frequency stability. Like all radios, bar none, all will drift some, just a matter of how much. 10 hz or 100hz ???? Well the Magnum 1 would come on cold in the morning at only 6~10 hz off center frequency and once warmed up for a little bit, it would come right on frequency and stay there. This radio is temperature controlled for frequency stability.
Do not use a power or amplified microphone with this radio. It has a built in Top Gun modulation compressor in it and any power or amplified microphone will drive it into over modulation very quickly. The stock microphone with this radio is very good sounding. And we tried several different mics.
My only downside to this radio is that it does not have the power output of the Stryker 955. The Magnum 1 tops out at 40 watts PEP on SSB and about 12 watts am dead key.
BUT, it does sound very good with the stock microphone.
And by the way, my friend uses a 500 watt amplifier behind his Magnum 1, so the lower power output compared to the 955 is not an issue for him.
I do believe you would be very satisfied with this radio.