In a case like this, a working part becomes a troubleshooting tool. Good luck!
Advice to change the mica cap dangling from the neutralizing-adjust trimcap is mostly bad. More important to have two final tubes that came from the same assembly line. The tubes have internal capacitance that determines the setting of the neutralizing cap. If one final tube has twice the internal capacitance of the other one, you'll never get it to set properly. So long as both tubes were constructed on the same assembly line, the internal structures that determine that capacitance should also be the same. And if one tube came from Holland, and the other one was made in Pennsylvania, there's a good chance that the final stage just won't neutralize no matter where the adjustment is set. I'm convinced this is the dominant reason for all of the "I can't get it to neutralize" gripes over the years.
73