I can't speak for any of the others you've listed, but I have had some experience with the High Sierra HS-1800Pro screwdriver antenna.
My use was for portable use, not mobile use. When I bought it, I was moving around a bit. So, I wanted something I could easily pack up and bring inside, or pack up and move. I also wanted a quick setup that didn't need a minimum of two people -- or take all day.
I had the 6' whip, the "Six Shooter" cap hat and cap hat extender, and a tripod. It was a breeze to set up, a cinch to take down, and performed marvelously. With the 6' whip, I could tune to a near 1:1 on the entirety of 80m, without the whip, I could tune the whole of the 6m band. From about 50miles away from Atlanta, GA USA I worked Canada, South America, west and eastern Europe and Africa with it and one contact with Alaska -- at a max of 100 watts.
The rig I use is an IC-7000.
The antenna was a bit pricey -- I believe I paid right around $800 for it (bought new from High Sierra directly). I ended up selling it and the funds from that started my foray into SDR.
If it wasn't for the price of the thing -- I'd certainly get another one. The ground radials it comes with work perfectly. Lay them on the ground, or do what I did and use garden staples to hold the end insulators down. Easy peasy.
Hope that helps you somewhat!
--Alex / KA4AAA
P.S. -- At local hamfests, I see the HS-1800's attached to all different kinds of vehicles, so its apparently quite popular.