One of the most missed reason for weird SWR problems, is the fact that modifying the radio's 54mhz trap coils will automatically skew the output. You can try everything to fix the SWR problem; but if those coils have been molested you are ultimately chasing your own tail.
I work ham radio from my truck and open doors do affect the readings.I don't see any difference in swr with my doors open, parked under power lines, driving down the road, etc. When I had common mode issues I had hell with all of this. Even the ground I was parked on made a difference with high power. Different swr on concrete vs dirt.
Even with the wilson mag mount on the work truck the swr is the same with the doors open or closed. If these little things make enough difference for concern I believe there is another issue.
543 Dallas, I am putting my Wilson 1000 mag mount back on the trunk lip of my car, and in the driveway where I am trying to tune my antenna to get the best swr for my radio I have residential power lines going overhead. I can't seem to get my swr below 2.0 on 1 and 40, I am guess I am wondering would trying too tune a antenna by powerlines,could it affect me trying too tune it properly, I have a brand new 62 inch whip in it and the coax is brand new also, I had the same antenna on a different car in the same spot and I was able to drop the whip in and got a 1.0 to 1.5 before. I am thinking i may have to trim a little off,but i was just wondering if residential power lines could affect tuning a cb antenna,hope the info helps!! Thanks...
With all the plastic in vehicles today & the sound deadening material they stuff in between panels it is almost impossible to get a real good ground.
With out a good ground it is hard to get a good vswr.
Try bonding the doors & trunk to the body frame.
I work ham radio from my truck and open doors do affect the readings.
It's a 2012 Hyundai Elantra and it's a a mag mount Wilson 1000 antenna if that info helps on the trunk lid!Not sure of the vehicle you're putting this on, but if you've got 1.5 SWR from a previous install using this antenna - verify that the antenna is still capable of giving you that 1.5 SWR - can you put it back on that other vehicle to verify?
Because we may be missing something...you said Trunk Lip, or Lid?
Oldtymer put it best...
Usually there is a "Seam" that the finish metal is epoxied onto the frame underneath onto that trunk lid frame. The way this is done, gives this finish metal the strength it does. And at the same time, seals it from the elements to prevent perforation rust thru. But it's thin finish metal for the exterior and tears like tin foil if you try to do anything more than look at it. And with the Epoxy there is little conduction - unfortunately most cars are now produced with as little spot welding as needed and the rest is all seamed and then stamped or epoxied. So you have little choice to "apply more ground" except to maybe relocate the mount closer to a trunk lid hinge area that you may be able to "pigtail" some braided wire or even a simple bonding strap so you can then apply the grounding the trunk lip mount has (it's setscrew(s)- onto the frame of the vehicle where that hinge assembly mounts to. (one of it's mounting bolts). This way may help enlarge the region it grounds to; in helping provide enough "Counterpoise" with small area SWR issues.
Splitting hairs for sure plus I only run mag mounts. The mag mounts are more touchy with incidental reactance of the surrounding area.How much of a change are we talking about. A significant amount or splitting hairs like 1.2 with the doors closed and 1.3 them open?
At a couple of kw I haven't noticed a change in swr with doors open vs closed. I have a fwd and reflect meter inline at all times. If were trying to split hairs theres probably a difference but I'm not looking that hard.
Before I installed the puck mount I had an antenna mounted to the bed. All kinds of things made the swr fluctuate. Especially with the power on.
No rear window defroster on my pickup.Oh, mag mount - trunk LID - got it, not lip...ok - well, do you have a rear defroster "Grid" that can affect SWR if the coil is close to it.
That's why it's best on the roof, there is no rear defroster on a Pickmeup - just a thing they call a "cab"
My last car a 2008 Chevrolet cobalt had a rear defroster and I had it in the same spot,no problem, I think I'll have to trim the whip a little bit.Oh, mag mount - trunk LID - got it, not lip...ok - well, do you have a rear defroster "Grid" that can affect SWR if the coil is close to it.
Else usually when they are on a truck bed or other "square pieces" that's is used, is/provides too small of surface run for waveshape (work with me here I'm talking about counterpoise and it's length in symmetry) and seems only to lower SWR in one edge or another - that is because as the antenna works the image in a counterpoise, remember it's attempting to make an image - so if there are location and length issues, well - you have what you're having now...
Care for a relocation effort or are we stuck with that spot?