B
i didn't catch the length of the vertical on the rod of god , but if its a full 1/2 wavelength .......... if it tx/rx any better than a antron 99 6 ft off the ground its because it has the vehicle for a ground plane . it should handle a lot more power though . for over a grand my question would be why stop at a 1/2 wl .... why not go to 5/8 or the magical .64 wl . or better yet (yea , im going there) stick a vector on top ?
i wonder if joe will make a rod of jesus ?
They were never sold for over a grand the DM antennas went for $550.00
Joe didnt invent or design the antenna he just sells something that someone else made like Fatboy profiting of off others ideas.
Snake oil, surely not?
That is hysterical on such a tiny car AND a magnet mount. He says no one can touch him?????? Anyone with a full size truck or SUV with a good solid roof mounted antenna would beat him.
So you are saying a 8.5' piece of copper antenna will be better than the rod of god which is a full 1/2 wave radiator that will handle how ever many Kw's you can throw at it.
In short, yes.
In long form, the "Rod of God" is a gimmick because it's almost entirely coil. Coils do a great job at turning wattage into waste. Now, in theory, a 1/2 wave antenna would have a superior radiation pattern over that of a 1/4 wave. However, a 1/2 wave antenna vs a 1/4 wave antenna in a BASE setting will produce very meager gains...somewhere in the realm of only 1 or 2 dB over the 1/4 wave.
Now lets add the huge coil to the mix. You now have a 1/2 wave heavily loaded antenna with a slightly better radiation pattern than 1/4 wave. However, that's after your AMP-OUT has been fed through about -9 dB worth of useless loading coil.
Versus the 8.5 ft 1/2" copper tube, which is an unloaded 1/4 wave...it produces a very slight gain of around or less than +1 db. In short, 1000w in is approximately 1000w radiated, maybe 1100w radiated with the very slight gain.
With the 1/2 wave "Rod of God"? 1000w in is approximately 125w radiated.
My math in this is very crude and I'm leaving out some stuff, but you get the picture.
since coils used as matching devices on base antennas dont produce 9 db of loss , why does mounting it on a mobile suddenly cause it to happen ?
adding %10 to the ERP of a antenna will never be noticed on 11 meters .
" ............. In short, 1000w in is approximately 1000w radiated, maybe 1100w radiated with the very slight gain ."
LOL OK