"google Pulseaudio sucks About 90,200 results (0.22 seconds)
So I'm not alone and this is something of a dead horse . If nothing else kicking it makes me feel better .
First of all a hearty double shot of mid-roasted Jamaican Blue Mountain to
idyllictux for an easy to follow and nearly complete method of holding the beast PA (PulseAudio) at bay .
I did say nearly complete .
It seems that through some incompletely documented update that I have yet to find ,vestiges of the dreaded beast have once again appeared in my machine . Starting Skype (that works just fine w/o PA btw) seems to produce a kidnapping of my audio hardware by a non-existent PA (having been completely removed as well as following the above link) and failing to release it even after a kill . Following this something as simple as "twinkle" aborts with "failure to access, audio device busy ..." and nothing short of a reboot so far has been a cure . I am still looking for the kidnapper with lsof | grep some such but not being a serious nerd the process of extracting resources used by an app and creating a diff from another app escape me . I just know it's broken .
Movies that played over my small home network now have to be imported whole and entire to the media center to play with anything approaching audio . Previously ALSA worked just fine . PA as a default addition to ubuntu for the sake of "put out something broken for the community to fix" rather than extensive testing in alpha/beta and multiple platforms is just plain irresponsible and wrong . Because of PA and it's invasive ,system wide intrusion 10.04 LTS is unavailable to me on not one but 4 different platforms . Simply editing /grub/menu.cfg directly in 10.04 to remove "quiet splash" allowed HID to load before PA and access to the keyboard was possible ! How is that for invasive ?
Sun Microsystems (may it rest in peace) made a good living out of being a solution in search of a problem for a good number of years but it worked .
The ubuntu community is not in need of under developed , operating system invasive (if you don't check the "items to be removed" in the synaptic dialog box when completely removing PA you will find your entire desktop environment gone) obfuscated from the user , insane machinations to make it work
try this if you have a spare week or so when simply it's eradication and removal would do the community more good in the short term and possibly be a lesson to the core developers that release to community in order to speed the maturity by way of bug reports and fixes is akin to a soup with 90,200 unhappy chefs producing an inedible brew . A solution in need of a problem indeed .
How about a solution to a problem for the benefit of the community . I don't recommend we line up PA against the wall with all the lawyers and shoot (sry , personal pet peeve ) but rather place PA in quarantine at the risk of it's further development taking place in a vacuum rather than in real world computing . PA may yet be the next thing but does anyone remember the lesson of application integration that was M$ internet explorer ? (and I'm not talking about the legal ramifications ) .
I full well realize that what I'm suggesting is a fork in ubuntu development , one with and one without PulseAudio . I think the time is well over due for the masses to be heard . Please , in a meaningful way , DEVELOPERS , ask your user base if PulseAudio has a place in their desktop as it is now ,not as some intend it to be . remember where good intentions get you .
Screw it I'm done . I'm FFFR away from leaving ubuntu simply over this one issue . I wonder if I'm alone . Other than the 90.200 hits I found on google
Last edited by kopcicle; June 12th, 2010 at 09:26 PM. Reason: to remove unrelated rant about liberal Democrats"
=============================================================
So, care to ask me any further questions about Pulse Audio or liberal democrats ?