i do not know myself. not having an older one to compare it to, i could only guess. perhaps there was such a vast quality control issue which would make sense as to why there is such a large varance in performance. i will post the last of the pic's this evening.
in anycase, i have done all i can do with it besides change the design which may be warrented to make it equal in performance to the sirio 5000 series antennae, which i have discovered in my research has a similar flaw like the wilsons do, which would be the top of the coil being set screwed into place in two positions rather than soldered, which could lead to swr issues over time. at this stage changing the design would be pointless. so i am going to epoxy the load casing back into position, make a final test and put it up for sale. although the project was fun to do, it was not worth the loss of $$$$ just for the learning experence.
i hope i have shed some light on why there seems to be so many problems with these antennae. if anyone at anytime would like to add to this thread please feel free to do so.
thanks to all for your interest.